Answer Close-Reading Questions
Have students write their responses, or use the Close-Reading Questions to guide a discussion.
• Why are officials in Panama planning to dam the Río Indio? Use text evidence to support your response. (Text Evidence)
Officials in Panama plan to dam the Río Indio to create a new reservoir that could replenish the Panama Canal during droughts. The text states, “Adding another reservoir could keep the canal running even during dry spells and potentially let more ships cross year-round.”
• How will damming the Río Indio affect the people who live near it? (Cause and Effect)
Once the dam is constructed, the Río Indio will flood its banks, creating a reservoir. The flooding will submerge nearby Indigenous communities. More than 3,000 people are expected to lose their homes and 10,000 more people could be affected in other ways.
• What additional sources would you consult to evaluate whether Panama’s plan to protect the canal is the best decision? What questions would you ask? (Evaluate a Claim)
Sample response: To evaluate the plan to preserve the Panama Canal, I would want to talk to engineers or other experts. I would ask: Are there solutions that could help preserve the Panama Canal without displacing people? What are the benefits and drawbacks of those ideas? In addition, I would want to hear from government officials about their plans to compensate and assist people who would be displaced. I would ask: Will people be given assistance with finding new jobs?